By all accounts, 23-year old Dana Ireland would have been successful at whatever she chose to do with her life. But she didn’t get that chance. On Christmas Eve, 1991, this blond-haired, blue-eyed young woman set off on her bicycle to invite a new friend to dinner at her parents’ vacation rental home in a rural Hawaii neighborhood. As she was riding back to the holiday meal, three local youths decided to celebrate Christmas in a different way. They followed her in their car, then rammed her bike, kidnapped, raped, and beat her, and left her for dead on an isolated spot overlooking the ocean. In a community where many residents left their doors unlocked, people were shocked and terrified by this random, brutal act of violence. Worse still was that if the authorities hadn’t taken so long to get to the victim, she might have lived. As months and years went by, frustration turned to outrage when police failed to arrest anyone for Dana’s murder. But from his home in Springfield, Virginia, John Ireland started his own dogged investigation and crusade for justice. And nine years after his daughter’s murder, after one of the most complicated cases the state had ever seen, three men were convicted. Here is a dramatic true story of a beautiful woman, a faulty legal system, and a father’s unwavering battle to find the truth.